Choosing the Right Cookware: Stainless Steel, Aluminum, Cast Iron, or Nonstick?

If you grew up in a typical African home between the '70s and early '00s, chances are you came across an African utensil rack. It was often placed outside the kitchen, next to a tap—if you were lucky enough to have running water.

A standout feature of this rack was the cooking pots sufurias. Depending on your mother’s cleaning habits—especially if firewood was the main cooking fuel—these pots were either blackened with years of soot or meticulously scrubbed to a shine, sometimes with just the bottom staying black.

Typical African home dish drying rack. Source: Alamy

Back then, keeping cookware clean was a labor-intensive task. Steel wool was a luxury for many, so women in the village used creative alternatives—small pieces of charcoal, ash, and even aged sackcloth—to scrub soot-stained pots. At gatherings like biathos and village parties, a thick layer of mud was smeared on pots before placing them over an open fire, making them easier to clean afterward.

Today, things are different. We have a variety of cookware options that make cooking and cleaning easier. Nonstick pans require nothing more than a simple wipe, aluminum heats up quickly, stainless steel offers durability, and cast iron retains heat exceptionally well. But which one is the best?

In this guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of stainless steel, aluminum, cast iron, and nonstick cookware to help you decide which suits your cooking needs best. Ultimately, the right choice comes down to personal preference and how you like to cook.

Stainless Steel Cookware

Stainless steel cookware.

Pros:

• Extremely durable and resistant to rust, corrosion, and scratches.

• Non-reactive, meaning it won’t alter the taste or color of acidic foods like tomatoes.

• Can handle high heat, making it ideal for searing and browning.

• Dishwasher safe and easy to maintain.

Cons:

• Poor heat conductivity unless combined with an aluminum or copper core.

• Food tends to stick unless the pan is properly heated and oiled.

• Can be expensive, especially high-quality brands.
  

Best for: Searing meats, making sauces, and versatile cooking. Ideal for those who want long-lasting cookware with a professional look.

Aluminum Cookware

Aluminium cookware

Pros:

• Lightweight and easy to handle.

• Excellent heat conductivity, ensuring quick and even heating.

• Generally more affordable than stainless steel or cast iron.

Cons:

• Highly reactive with acidic and alkaline foods, which can affect flavor.

• Prone to warping and scratching if not treated carefully.

• Can leach aluminum into food if it’s not anodized or coated.

Best for: Fast cooking, such as boiling, frying, and making quick stir-fries. Ideal for those on a budget or who prefer lightweight cookware.

Cast Iron Cookware

Cast iron cookware

Pros:

• Excellent heat retention, keeping food warm long after cooking.

• Naturally nonstick when well-seasoned.

• Extremely durable, often lasting for generations.

• Adds iron to your diet, which can be beneficial.

Cons:

• Very heavy and can be difficult to maneuver.

• Requires regular seasoning to maintain its nonstick properties.

• Prone to rust if not dried properly after washing.

• Takes longer to heat up compared to aluminum or stainless steel.

Best for: Frying, baking, and slow-cooking dishes like stews. Ideal for those who enjoy traditional cooking methods and don’t mind a little extra maintenance.

Nonstick Cookware (Teflon, granite, die cast)

Granite cookware

Pros:

• Food doesn’t stick, making cooking and cleaning effortless.

• Requires less oil, promoting healthier cooking.

• Lightweight and easy to use.

Cons:

• Coating can wear off over time, especially if used with metal utensils.

• Not suitable for high-heat cooking as extreme temperatures can damage the coating.

• Some low-quality nonstick coatings contain harmful chemicals that can release toxic fumes if overheated.

• 
  

Best for: Delicate foods like eggs, pancakes, and fish. Ideal for those who prioritize convenience and easy cleanup.

Which Cookware Should You Choose?

Each type of cookware has its strengths and weaknesses, and the best choice depends on your cooking habits and preferences.

If you want a durable, long-lasting option, stainless steel or cast iron might be ideal. If you prefer quick and even heating, aluminum is a great choice. And if you value convenience and easy cleanup, nonstick cookware is hard to beat.

At the end of the day, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. Many home cooks find that a combination of different cookware types works best. So, whether you're frying, searing, boiling, or slow-cooking, the right cookware can enhance your cooking experience and make meal preparation easier.

Choose what fits your needs and enjoy the art of cooking! Shop here.